Small width layout Medium width layout Maximum width layout Small text Medium text Large text
     Search
Downloads Downloads Directory Directory Forums Forums Forge Forge Blogs Blogs        Marketplace Marketplace Careers Program Careers
Community › Forums Register  |  

Affordable ASP.NET Hosting Service
  Ads  
Engage Software - Training Partner for DotNetNuke
 


  Sponsors  

Meet Our Sponsors

WebSecureStores -- ASP.NET & DotNetNuke Hosting Solutions
FCKeditor Project
Salaro -- Skins and more
OnyakTech
CrystalTech Web Hosting™
Webhost4life, specialists in DNN hosting
 


DotNetNuke Forums
 
  Forum  General DotNetN...  Chat About It!  The Problem with Forums
Previous Previous
 
Next Next
New Post 8/19/2008 5:47 PM
User is offline mhh12
6 posts
10th Ranked


The Problem with Forums 

I've done a lot of forum reading lately because I have wanted answers as to how to make software work. And so I am going to take the horn by the bull and tell you why forums are worthless.

First of all, they are not written in gramatically correct English. Sorry, Charlie, pigeon English doesn't cut it. And so both the questions and the responses are cryptic or ambiguous or worthless. Take your pick.

Questions should be written so responders understand the question. This means you have to furnish documentation. You have to identify the form where the problem occurred; you have to say exactly what you wrote; you have to say exactly how you got there. You have to identify alternatives you have tried and that don't work and you have to suggest alternatives. Yes, I know it takes time to  write the background for the question. But look how long it takes to finally get an answer. Tell the whole story in the  beginning and save yourself calendar time. The questions indicate the writers, including myself, have no idea how all this internet programming actually works. Which ought to give the responders a clue as to how to write a response.

When you read the answers, it's pretty obvious the background to the question wasn't given adequately. It's also pretty obvious that some responders are simply responding off the top of their heads and many haven't the vaguest idea of how to solve the problem. The key  point, for those who are qualified to answer the question, is they have to leave their techie language behind and write in plain old fashioned English. The hard point to comprehend is the response is not an opportunity to show off how smart you are; it is a time  to communicate the answer to the problem. And so it has to be written in plain, old fashioned grammically correct English with no technical words. You have to tell the questioner how to click through and fill  out forms to solve the problem. That's something he canunderstand. 

Yes, I know. You really didn't want to hear this. But until the writers of the software want to step up and respond and as long as they let us users, who really don't have their knowledge, respond, us users got to learn to do it right. How do you like that for good English?

 

 
New Post 8/19/2008 6:39 PM
User is offline ROBAX
1875 posts
5th Ranked


Re: The Problem with Forums 

This would be true, if this were a commercial product, and if the forum were provided as the customer support solution for the product. Neither is the case here so the assessment really isn't accurate at all.

In fact, the forum and the support provided by English and non-English speakers makes it by far the most important and valuable communications and support tool here. The real shocker, as you've noted in your post, is that by this November the forum will have been in place for an entire year with very serious usability issues. If this were a commercial product then it would deserve to fail... but it ain't, so whilst I personallt appreciate the points made, be prepared to take some flack.

I'm also very seldom offended, but the comment about 'Charlie' is quite simply racist.

Rob

 
New Post 8/19/2008 9:11 PM
User is offline Cuong Dang
285 posts
engagesoftware.com
9th Ranked


Re: The Problem with Forums 
Modified By Cuong Dang  on 8/19/2008 11:11:54 PM)

I am Vietnamese, also a part of this community, and offended by the word "Charlie".


Cuong Dang
Engage Software
St. Louis, MO
314.966.4000



The leading provider of DotNetNuke support, training and custom module development.
 
New Post 8/19/2008 11:21 PM
User is offline Leazon
267 posts
9th Ranked


Re: The Problem with Forums 

Cuong-

I could be wrong but I think the "Sorry Charlie" the poster may be referring to is more of an age thing.

The poster could be using the phrase made poplular by the fish in the old Starkist tuna commercial  - where the fish's name is Charlie and get's told by the announcer "Sorry Charlie only the best tuna get to be Starkist".  It was a pretty poplular phrase years ago - kind of like "Where's the beef?"

Then again I could just be really old and not have the slightest clue what I'm talking about.

I hope I'm right because it would be way un-cool for language like that to be used in this forum.

P.S. Bonus points if you can remember when that commercial aired - had to be 60's or 70's

 

 
New Post 8/19/2008 11:25 PM
User is offline Carlos Rodriguez
526 posts
www.almacigo.com
8th Ranked


Re: The Problem with Forums 

"Sorry Charlie" is a phrase from an old StarKist tuna commercial, it is not meant to be offensive, you two may not know this reference so lighten up.

Read this.

By the way, notice that I am non-white and in my 20+ years career in IT have endured crap from white, black, and yellow alike.

Therefore, where's the beef???

Carlos

 

 
Previous Previous
 
Next Next
  Forum  General DotNetN...  Chat About It!  The Problem with Forums
 


Forum Policy

These Discussion Forums are dedicated to the discussion of the DotNetNuke Web Application Framework.

For the benefit of the community and to protect the integrity of the project, please observe the following posting guidelines:

1. No Advertising. This includes promotion of commercial and non-commercial products or services which are not directly related to DotNetNuke.
2. Discussion or promotion of DotNetNuke product releases under a different brand name are strictly prohibited.
3. No Flaming or Trolling.
4. No Profanity, Racism, or Prejudice.
5. Site Moderators have the final word on approving/removing a thread or post or comment.
6. English language posting only, please.

 


Software Development and Integration with DNN
HNP Solutions focuses on the pragmatic use of technology and process to meet an organization's business objectives. HNP Solutions employs seasoned Enterprise and Solution Architects, Delivery Managers and QA & Business Leads. Our capabilities range from project assessments & recommendations, design & code reviews, to full program implementations. We also work with organizations in need of senior staff augmentation purposes in the areas of Enterprise and Solution architecture.
www.hnpsolutions.com
Alki Homes - Seattle, WA
Exemplary service for your Seattle Real Estate needs. It's what you deserve from your Realtor®!
www.alkihomes.com
PointClick DotNetNuke Solutions
PointClick Technologies provides high-end DNN Hosting for businesses.
PointClick.Net Hosted Solutions

DotNetNuke Corporation   Terms Of Use  Privacy Statement
DotNetNuke®, DNN®, and the DotNetNuke logo are trademarks of DotNetNuke Corporation
Hosted by MaximumASP