Thank you. Unfortunately, that doesn't work.
I go to the "Forum Configuration" screen and maximize the subset called "User Settings" where I find "Trust New Users" and "Lock New User Trust Setting". Both are unchecked. I have tried every combination of checked and unchecked on these two boxes.
I have tried a similar thing under "Forum Administration>Forum Users" where I attempt to change the trust status for an individual user. Here I have also checked or unchecked the "Lock Trust" box.
None of these variations allow me to uncheck the "Trusted User" box for an individual user. That box remains checked and grayed out.
Thank you for the pointer to the user manual. According to that, I should not be seeing this problem.