Small width layout Medium width layout Maximum width layout Small text Medium text Large text
     Search
Downloads Downloads Directory Directory Forums Forums Forge Forge Blogs Blogs        Marketplace Marketplace Careers Program Careers
Community › Forums Register  |  

PortalWebHosting
  Need Help?  
Professional technical support for DotNetNuke is available from DotNetNuke Corporation.
 


  Ads  
Aspose - The .NET & Java component publisher
 


  Sponsors  

Meet Our Sponsors

telerik
ExactTarget email software solutions
Merak Mail Server
WebSecureStores -- ASP.NET & DotNetNuke Hosting Solutions
FCKeditor Project
Salaro -- Skins and more
 


DotNetNuke Forums
 
  Forum  DotNetNuke® Pro...  Forum Module [L...  Anonymous posting
Previous Previous
 
Next Next
New Post 6/15/2006 3:34 PM
User is offline Hooligannes
1558 posts
www.nesinteractivos.com
5th Ranked






Re: Anonymous posting 
 s2k wrote

And the issue I have is how the reply was made, it came across as being a personal view that the feature was stupid and thus it was not needed. "I personally object the addition of this "feature""

Sorry to have raised any ill will, it jsut came off poorly to me in how it sounded.

If the majority don't want it then don't add it that is fine, as I said those that need it can go elsewhere.  I as well don't like anon posting personally but I answer to my clients needs not only my personal views.

It's funny that you disqualify my personal objection, by an assumption that "it comes accross that it is a stupid feature". Why on earth would I provide a workaround then? I answered to users needs as I saw within the limits of my capabilities. Plus, my reply was factual. I was flamed for my opinion. That's OK, I was in no obligation to provide anything yet I did. Shame on me for trying.


Do you know the truth when you hear it?
The Dúnadan Raptor
Check My Blog for DNN advice and more
 
New Post 6/15/2006 3:51 PM
User is offline Mark Langille
267 posts
9th Ranked


Re: Anonymous posting 
 hooligannes wrote
 s2k wrote

And the issue I have is how the reply was made, it came across as being a personal view that the feature was stupid and thus it was not needed. "I personally object the addition of this "feature""

Sorry to have raised any ill will, it jsut came off poorly to me in how it sounded.

If the majority don't want it then don't add it that is fine, as I said those that need it can go elsewhere.  I as well don't like anon posting personally but I answer to my clients needs not only my personal views.

It's funny that you disqualify my personal objection, by an assumption that "it comes accross that it is a stupid feature". Why on earth would I provide a workaround then? I answered to users needs as I saw within the limits of my capabilities. Plus, my reply was factual. I was flamed for my opinion. That's OK, I was in no obligation to provide anything yet I did. Shame on me for trying.

Forget I ever said anything on the topic at all,  as I see where this is headed.

Thanks for all the hard work, I will say no more on this topic.

 
New Post 6/15/2006 3:55 PM
User is offline Mark Langille
267 posts
9th Ranked


Re: Anonymous posting 
 ErikVB wrote

S2K, could you perhaps elaborate on the use case your client has for anonymous forums? To me it seems rather pointless to have anonymous forums.. it would become more like something of a blog, or guestbook even....

cheers,

Erik

The client wanted people to be able to reply to forum posts without the need to register as this was for an event with thousands of possible people involved and they didnlt want everyone to register just to make a single reply.

I suggested against this due to possible spamming and bad posts but they wanted this and would moderate any nonsense.

The stock module apparently does not nor will nto support this, which is fine.  I can either modify the code or buy one of the other forum modules that does have the feature. 

That is all I have to say as this seem to be a sore spot of discusion and I'm not here to cause issues.

 
New Post 6/28/2006 9:10 AM
User is offline Kenneth Courtney
92 posts
aciasoftware.com
10th Ranked


Re: Anonymous posting 
 ErikVB wrote

S2K, could you perhaps elaborate on the use case your client has for anonymous forums? To me it seems rather pointless to have anonymous forums.. it would become more like something of a blog, or guestbook even....

cheers,

Erik

I have one. My daughter, Natalie, recently passed away at 18 months old. She was fighting a rare form of cancer known as Rhabdoid Tumor of the Kidney. While fighting this cancer, I often posted to and received good information from a very old forum used by www.rhabdoidkids.com on disc.server.com. As much as I hated this old forum software that only allowed searching on a single key word and was virtually unsearchable with google since several thousand forums are hosted on it's URL (using 'Search this site' functionality), many people who used it loved it because it offered them the ability to post anonymously for whatever reason.

I think I am not alone in the thinking that if someone ones to contribute anonymously to a dialog that may save a child's life with this disease, by all rights, let them contribute anonymously!

Speaking of Forking, although not nearly as integrated as the core forums, YetAnotherForum.net does offer a complete, multi-portal FREE solution to implementing forums in your dotnetnuke site already that does support anonymous posting. I would personally rather use the core forums as overall, they are far superior to any other solution (ActiveModules Active Forums are great, but cost $$$'s and don't offer (at least for my version) a free upgrade path), but if that is what I have to do to, that is what i will have to do.

Speaking of Active Module's Active Forums, it took me the better part of four hours to get the version my client purchased on www.virtualrap.com to work with DNN 3.3, but I was able to.

-Kenneth S. Courtney

 
New Post 6/28/2006 5:22 PM
User is offline Matt
2 posts
10th Ranked


Re: Anonymous posting 
Since the people here are so damn short-sighted allow me to provide a few illustrations for why the possibility of anonymous or non-registered posting can be very beneficial:

1. I am making a family reunion website--a place for extended family to keep in touch and plan future reunions and develop family history. The CMS that I am planning to install must have a forum module that allows unregistered users to post messages because my family has a lot of older computer-illiterate people. Half of those with enough know-how to turn a computer on and find the website would be baffled by a retarded registration process. We aren't concerned about spammers or trolls and such. There should be some basic option that someone could just type in a name and post a message without being registered if that’s what the owners of the site want.

2. This is likely the only post I am going to make on this forum....ever. So I don't really care about having an account here. Yet, just to add my 2 cents, it took 30 minutes for the completely unnecessary verification email to finally show up so that I could post. Many places such as various tech support websites like this one would benefit from not restricting the flow of ideas on their websites. Make it easy for people to post and then more people will contribute! Registration is a deterrent to the flow of ideas.

3. Here is an example of a game community that allows people to post anonymously or to register if they choose to. I've posted there for several years and it has worked great. http://comm.strategy.thardferr.com/forum/
 
Previous Previous
 
Next Next
  Forum  DotNetNuke® Pro...  Forum Module [L...  Anonymous posting
 


Forum Policy

These Discussion Forums are dedicated to the discussion of the DotNetNuke Web Application Framework.

For the benefit of the community and to protect the integrity of the project, please observe the following posting guidelines:

1. No Advertising. This includes promotion of commercial and non-commercial products or services which are not directly related to DotNetNuke.
2. Discussion or promotion of DotNetNuke product releases under a different brand name are strictly prohibited.
3. No Flaming or Trolling.
4. No Profanity, Racism, or Prejudice.
5. Site Moderators have the final word on approving/removing a thread or post or comment.
6. English language posting only, please.

 


Efficion Consulting
A premier DotNetNuke consulting firm providing complete DNN services including: custom module development, skinning and design, installation and integration services.
www.efficionconsulting.com
DotNetNuke Training by Engage Software
Specializing in customized training, architecture and module solutions for large scale implementations lead by DNN Core Team Member Christopher Hammond.
engagesoftware.com
Smart-Thinker
DNN Modules for Social Networks for as low as $69 for 6 modules! We also maintain the DotNetNuke Directory - http://DNNDir.com
www.smart-thinker.com

DotNetNuke Corporation   Terms Of Use  Privacy Statement
DotNetNuke®, DNN®, and the DotNetNuke logo are trademarks of DotNetNuke Corporation
Hosted by MaximumASP