I'm developing a political site and the ability to allow users to post their opinions anonymously is very important. Without this ability, the folks making the decisions on the look and feel of the site will probably scrap the forum completely.
I read the first 4 pages of this thread and came across Chris's thorough response so I wanted to just jump in for a minute. The canned forum module is great but I feel that requiring folks to log in to post a message is a major shortfall and I'm curious why such functionality (parameter-driven), was never introduced in the early stages. Assuming someone will be moderating and controlling the posts, I don't see any reason not to allow folks to post threads without being logged in.
In the case of this political website I'm doing, many people viewing the site will not be technically savvy enough to go through the registration process (or may choose not to provide their personal information), and as such, their voices will not be heard.
I'm frankly quite surprised that the developers of this module have not received sufficient "demand" from the user base for this parameter. Please keep up the good work, but please put this on your 'to-do' list!